Comparison Cicuta with others
[Peter Kern]
Nux-m. very absentminded. Kent mentions the typical example
of the housewife interrupted in her tasks and unable to remember what she was
just doing minutes ago.
Where Cicuta feels absences and withdraws into his
thoughts, Nux moschata feels extremely drowsy with a dryness of the mouth quite
characteristic because devoid of thirst. Moreover, there is a tendency to
fainting and to digestive bloating which is not found in Cicuta.
Nat-m. the major differential
diagnosis with Cicuta and to which it can be compared as far as absences and
other tendencies to be lost in thoughts are concerned.
Nat-m.keeps reminiscing on and on about sad
thoughts of the past, unlike Cicuta. Nat-m.is very reserved, just like Cicuta
when on the defensive. Nat-m.also has many alimentary signs which differ from
Cicuta, and above all he is improved by physical exertion, which is rarely
found in other remedies.
- Anxiety
about the future
This symptom is another that leads to
understanding this unfamiliar remedy which appears at the 3rd grade in the
rubric and deserves our attention. It is not (or rarely) anticipation, as found
in Med,
Lyc
or Carc,
but a real anxiety about the future with a hardly disguised pessimism.
Cicuta is often interested in the fate of humanity
and is very worried about its future. Sometimes, the patient is more concerned
about himself with the fear of falling
ill or of the occurrence of a catastrophe. In this
case, Cicuta is very close to Sulphur on the philosophical side.
Sulph. often looks like the ragged philosopher as
described by Hering, but Cicuta can also be totally unconcerned with his
appearance (Indifference/ External things),
which leads to the confusion between the two
remedies.
Sulph always has a joy of living and convivial
side, unlike Cicuta, even though the remedy can be found at the 3rd degree in
the Gaiety heading under cheerfulness.
On the contrary, Cicuta is often a disappointed
person who can still be in a good mood at moments, even though he might try
more and more to turn his back on the world
and no longer feels concerned.
A distinctive mental sign
These notions just described set the scene. We now
have to focus on the symptom which is the key to the remedy.
Mind: Shuns the foolishness of men; or Misanthropy,
shuns the foolishness of men. We see here that Cic. is the only remedy in the
rubric.
In Allen we find this symptom:
Contempt and scorn for mankind; he avoided them,
abhorred their follies excessively, and his disposition seemed to tend towards
misanthropy; he withdrew himself into solitude.
Cic. like Nat-m., is a very sensitive and bashful
person. Here follows a set of characteristic rubrics in my usual format. This
means the principal number is the remedy grade. The comma indicates that the
remedy has a relative valorization; i.e. 3,2 means third grade, two points
relative strength. With a slash, the following number is the rubrics size:
Excitement, horrible things, after hearing (1).
Frightened easily (1). Men, shuns foolishness of (1/1). Mildness (1).
Misanthropy, shuns foolishness of men (1/1). Narrating her complaints agg (1).
Sadness, sad stories (3/1).. Sensitiveness, sad stories (3,2/1). Sympathetic
(2). Talking, unpleasant things agg (1).
This short list of symptoms will enable us to
explain why Cicuta needs to run away from what is unbearable to him. Let’s
notice here the similarity with Pulsatilla’s gentle,
nice and very compassionate sides. Both remedies
aggravated when they have to talk about their symptoms. While Cicuta seeks
safety in escape and withdrawal,
Puls needs affection and will do everything to get
it. Basically gentle and compassionate, the Cicuta subject feels shocked by the
realities of society or human behaviors which do not agree with his own moral
values.
One of my patients, whom I had unsuccessfully
treated with Nat-m, then with various other remedies for his skinny, depressed
and very introverted sides, was totally transformed with Cicuta. During the war
in Yugoslavia, interrupting his current business and life, he volunteered to
drive lorries delivering vital supplies to civil populations.
He considered it was his duty as a human being to
go and bring assistance to those in need. Once over there, he was very
disappointed, to the point of feeling deceived by
the behavior of a lot of these supposed
volunteers. He was also badly shocked by awful stories he heard there.
Back home, he withdrew more and more, rarely going
out of his home. When consulting, he hated to talk about these very personal
subjects, saying he would prefer not to think about them.
Staphysagria has a romantic, nostalgic side, possibly
found in Cicuta, as well as an extreme sensitiveness for “external
impressions”, as mentioned in texts, that is a tendency
to easily feel offended or look on the bad side of
things, etc…
The subject who needs Staph often has a personal
history of injustice, whereas Cicuta is disappointed with human beings’
behaviour. Cicuta runs away from humanity’s stupidity, he’s not so affected by
personal injustice. Staph also shows a strong sexual excitation, a strong
desire for spicy foods and tends to produce condylomata, styes, cystitis…
We see that the Cicuta patient does not feel like
going out of his home or, when he has to go out, he wants to come back as soon
as possible. This tendency to stay home
is very evocative, and although it could be
mistaken with the Nat-m withdrawal, two other remedies should also be
mentioned:
Bryonia, has a fear of the future, is easily
irritated against others and has a yearning to go home. Bry is down to earth,
he does not think for one minute about mankind’s well being, his anxiety for
the future is due to his fear of being deprived and the yearning to go home is
linked to his aversion for movement.
Baryta carbonica likes to stay home and
is afraid of the future. This is due to his shyness and his extreme lack of
confidence in himself. His home, a familiar environment with well known marks,
is a haven of peace which secures him. The fear of the future can be explained by
the fact that Bar-c is aware of his deficiencies and lives in the future with a
lot of anticipation.
Lycopodium has a great duality. He is bossy in
well known situations, but becomes respectful of authority and “established
order” with unfamiliar people. Cicuta is not as cowardly and rather tries to
pick a quarrel with provocative attitudes to have an opportunity of loudly
voicing his indignation.
Quite often patients will say “I have become
vindictive and I send everyone to hell”. On the other hand, Cicuta is neither
in a bad mood when waking up, nor does he show the Lycopodium domineering
character. On the contrary, he will often make fun of authority which he feels
rarely based on merit. Both remedies show bloating and stomach ache symptoms:
Cicuta’s stomach pain may occur very suddenly. As Cicuta has also a sweaty head
while sleeping, this can lead to confusion with Lycopodium.
Causticum is very sensitive to social issues. The (young)
patient can easily be identified with his warts around finger nails and clearly
marked food likings. He is an authoritarian who likes salt or smoked food.
Cicuta is not afraid of the dark, nor does he have the need to be accompanied
or have someone hold his hand when going to sleep, like the Causticum child.
Both remedies show very deep compassion and are
truly able to act in favor of those in need. This will typically make Causticum
cry, but I think that both remedies are quite similar here. Causticum is improved
with dampness, has paretic signs (voice, urines) not to be found in Cicuta.
We have just drawn the picture of a sensitive
person with high views on humanity’s future, but who is hit hard by reality
which he finds sordid (more than anyone else would do).
An external aggression, may it be a shock on the
nervous tissue or a simple sting, fully reveals the convulsive nature of the
remedy. As far as perforating wounds are concerned, the major indications are
of course Ledum palustre and Hypericum.
With Ledum, we see coldness of the wounded areas,
although the patient does not feel the cold.
Hypericum is indicated when the same trauma
damages the nerves, with the presence of strong shooting pains (neuritis).
Here, we see that Cicuta induces convulsions through reflex effect of the
nerves, which is not at all the case with the two other remedies. However
before the discovery of Ledum, Cicuta was used fairly efficiently in prevention
of tetanus. If we get back to the signs following
cranial trauma (Coronaimpfung?!), Cicuta can develop convulsions, as well as
convergent strabismus (not listed in the repertory), or an anxiodepressive
condition.
In this case, we could think of Nat-s., especially
as Cicuta can also have suicidal ideas. Like all Natrum remedies, Nat-s.
is sensitive and uncommunicative, but as indicated by Vermeulen, he is the less
sensitive one and the most uncommunicative of all Natriums. These people are
very realistic, objective, not spontaneous, down to earth, very responsible and
with a strong sense of duty, etc… Here again, Cicuta differs with his
particular sensitiveness to humanity and human beings in general. Cicuta’s
sense of duty is directed towards humanity, whereas Nat-s is more self centered
or for his close ones.
Vorwort/Suchen Zeichen/Abkürzungen Impressum